360 VS PS3 (A, AA, AAA) 2010 FINALIZED

Optimus Lime wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/heavyrainchroniclesepisode1thetaxidermist

Another one to add, MLD.

Isnt that DLC?

lightlamp2 wrote:

Optimus Lime wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/heavyrainchroniclesepisode1thetaxidermist

Another one to add, MLD.

Isnt that DLC?

Yeah, but it still gets added, doesn't it?

Optimus Lime wrote:

lightlamp2 wrote:

Optimus Lime wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/heavyrainchroniclesepisode1thetaxidermist

Another one to add, MLD.

Isnt that DLC?

Yeah, but it still gets added, doesn't it?

we add full games. Ive made no mention of including DLC to full games.

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/xbox360/supremecommander2

Dropped down to "A" status.


It's weird how not many PSN games get reviewed, take a look at this; http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/anarchyrushhour

Only one review, and because of that it can't get added to the list.

Damn it dropped 2 points to 78, hope it can climb its way back up

Optimus Lime wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/xbox360/supremecommander2

Dropped down to "A" status.


It's weird how not many PSN games get reviewed, take a look at this; http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/anarchyrushhour

Only one review, and because of that it can't get added to the list.

Keep me posted on PSN games if they make the list. I was tracking Wakeboarding HD but it looks like it wont make the cut.

Q1 went almost exactly how I hoped (thought MLB would get AA but nothing we cant compensate for). In fact it went even better because I didn't know we had the 360 "A" games coming out, and therefore were a pleasant surprise. The XBLA vs PSN gap is also better then I expected.

Q2 is where MS hits Sony hard. Lets say for arguments sake Modnation Racers (PS3 only Q2 retail game coming up) gets AAA.......that puts us behind 2 AAA and 1 AA game.

However we change that with our 3 games. I estimate Splinter Cell and Crackdown 2 will both end up with a AA score........thus making us win in the AA category. I think Alan Wake has the best shot at AAA status, thus making PS3 only lead us by 1 AAA game.

We will also widen our "A" gap with the possible additions of Ninety Nine Nights 2 and Sniper: Ghost Warrior. The XBLA vs PSN gap will only widen.

So by the end of June, we should have a lead in the AA, A, and downloadable categories, enough to offset PS3s one AAA game lead in that category.

GeneralMLD wrote:

Q1 went almost exactly how I hoped (thought MLB would get AA but nothing we cant compensate for). In fact it went even better because I didn't know we had the 360 "A" games coming out, and therefore were a pleasant surprise. The XBLA vs PSN gap is also better then I expected.

Q2 is where MS hits Sony hard. Lets say for arguments sake Modnation Racers (PS3 only Q2 retail game coming up) gets AAA.......that puts us behind 2 AAA and 1 AA game.

However we change that with our 3 games. I estimate Splinter Cell and Crackdown 2 will both end up with a AA score........thus making us win in the AA category. I think Alan Wake has the best shot at AAA status, thus making PS3 only lead us by 1 AAA game.

We will also widen our "A" gap with the possible additions of Ninety Nine Nights 2 and Sniper: Ghost Warrior. The XBLA vs PSN gap will only widen.

So by the end of June, we should have a lead in the AA, A, and downloadable categories, enough to offset PS3s one AAA game lead in that category.

i agree 95 percent,by the looks of it.splinter cell conviction will be a low AAA..and modnation racers doesn't look anything special,it most likely will be high AA

man, wat great gamez are coming for 360

GeneralMLD wrote:

Optimus Lime wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/xbox360/supremecommander2

Dropped down to "A" status.


It's weird how not many PSN games get reviewed, take a look at this; http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/anarchyrushhour

Only one review, and because of that it can't get added to the list.

Keep me posted on PSN games if they make the list. I was tracking Wakeboarding HD but it looks like it wont make the cut.

I'll try... I don't like PS3/PSN that much though.

I suggest putting the metacritic scores next to the games. Even though 80 and 89 are AA games, there is a huge difference of 9 points.

^^^^

no it makes things more complicated. simplicity is key.

u can add the new valkryie profile exclusive to the 360 and do PS3 minis count?

AndrejTheReviewer wrote:

360 may win this year.most wii games are going to be AA and i guess mario galaxy 2 will be AAA,other than that wii doesnt have much,ps3 only has gow 3 this month and if last guardian is coming out this year,its hard to tell if gt5 is going to be released this year

theres a new super mario galaxy!?!?!?!! :O
lol lookin forward to that, watch it get another 98 or sumthin lol

midgetshotgunner wrote:

u can add the new valkryie profile exclusive to the 360 and do PS3 minis count?

I never thought about PS3 minis. There's LOTS of them that are exclusive to PS3 alas they don't get reviewed. So like other PSN games that don't get reviewed either do the PS3 minis so it's a loss loss for ps3.

Optimus Lime wrote:

midgetshotgunner wrote:

u can add the new valkryie profile exclusive to the 360 and do PS3 minis count?

I never thought about PS3 minis. There's LOTS of them that are exclusive to PS3 alas they don't get reviewed. So like other PSN games that don't get reviewed either do the PS3 minis so it's a loss loss for ps3.

PS3 minis? Is that the equivalant of Xbox 360 Indie games? Cause several of those come out every week for 360 yet none get reviewed.

So yes i think its about even. PS3 minis and xbox indie games dont get reviewed.

GeneralMLD wrote:

Optimus Lime wrote:

midgetshotgunner wrote:

u can add the new valkryie profile exclusive to the 360 and do PS3 minis count?

I never thought about PS3 minis. There's LOTS of them that are exclusive to PS3 alas they don't get reviewed. So like other PSN games that don't get reviewed either do the PS3 minis so it's a loss loss for ps3.

PS3 minis? Is that the equivalant of Xbox 360 Indie games? Cause several of those come out every week for 360 yet none get reviewed.

So yes i think its about even. PS3 minis and xbox indie games dont get reviewed.

PS3 minis are small, cheap downloadable games. I think they also work on your PSP.

Guys...PS3 minis and Xbox Indie games suck anyways lol, who cares. You can find better games on Kongregate or something.

GeneralMLD wrote:

^^^^

no it makes things more complicated. simplicity is key.

I like that idea. An 89 is counted as AA but a 90 is AAA? The games are practically the same in quality.

GeneralMLD wrote:

Optimus Lime wrote:

midgetshotgunner wrote:

u can add the new valkryie profile exclusive to the 360 and do PS3 minis count?

I never thought about PS3 minis. There's LOTS of them that are exclusive to PS3 alas they don't get reviewed. So like other PSN games that don't get reviewed either do the PS3 minis so it's a loss loss for ps3.

PS3 minis? Is that the equivalant of Xbox 360 Indie games? Cause several of those come out every week for 360 yet none get reviewed.

So yes i think its about even. PS3 minis and xbox indie games dont get reviewed.

Lol yer but it's not even how psn games don't get reviewed.

Also SC:C is up on metacritic with a score of 91 AAA.

Check Metacritic, guys. Conviction is AA :sad:

this is the one time where I wished I didnt call it

GeneralMLD wrote:

this is the one time where I wished I didnt call it

At least you can stand by your prediction and they are often true.

- not being a fanboy at all, but, don't let metacritic judge games/make your opinion .

what i'm saying is:
Did you think WKC deserved the low score it got?
Or, did you think GTA4 deserved the highest score?

Metal Gear Solid should've been there . or Gears .

Sir.Zillah wrote:

- not being a fanboy at all, but, don't let metacritic judge games/make your opinion .

what i'm saying is:
Did you think WKC deserved the low score it got?
Or, did you think GTA4 deserved the highest score?

Metal Gear Solid should've been there . or Gears .

offcoruse not. this is purely a way to see what "the industry" thinks is a better library.

we can still buy what we like.