Fight Metacritic!

I'm sure I'm not the only one who have noticed a lot of titles getting undeserved scores by critics. Whether they be ridiculously high or unfairly low.
So here, we make up the rules. Which games do you think deserve what score?

In my opinion:
This is AAA

This is AAA

This is AAA

This is AA

This is high A or AA


THIS IS SPARTA!!!!


Now it's your turn!

AAA:

Heavy Rain (87)
Fable III (80)
Prince of Persia: The Forgotten Sands (75)
Fallout: New Vegas (84)
Left 4 Dead (89)

AA:

3D Dot Game Heroes (77)
Deadly Premonition (66)
Gears of War 2 (93)

A:

White Knight Chronicles (64)
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (94)
Call of Duty: World at War (84)

Below A:

Dante's Inferno (75)

A


AA


A


AA


A


AA


AAA


And who could forget the legend?
AAA

I first im not too sure about metacritic scores for example New Vegas and Fable 3 getting AA, but after a while I understand why they have. main'y cause of the bugs and glitches they have.

Yeah! I agree with most of those! Gears, killzone and uncharted shouldnt have such a high rating. A good rating, yes but not AAA IMO.
Btw red dead deserves AAA I think. But just a straight up 90

Gears, KZ and uncharted certainly dserved AAA scores DDD!

Arbiteris wrote:

Gears, KZ and uncharted certainly dserved AAA scores DDD!

Only Gears 1

BlackStigma wrote:

Arbiteris wrote:

Gears, KZ and uncharted certainly dserved AAA scores DDD!

Only Gears 1

No, Gears 2 had a much better single player.

Arbiteris wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

Arbiteris wrote:

Gears, KZ and uncharted certainly dserved AAA scores DDD!

Only Gears 1

No, Gears 2 had a much better single player.

True, but the multiplayer was nowhere near as good.

Mass Effect 1 = AA
Mass Effect 2 = AAA

DemonWolf wrote:

Yeah! I agree with most of those! Gears, killzone and uncharted shouldnt have such a high rating. A good rating, yes but not AAA IMO.
Btw red dead deserves AAA I think. But just a straight up 90

WHAT DRUGS HAVE YOU BEEN ON?

Mass Effect 1 = AAA
Mass Effect 2= C-

DarkSwarm85 wrote:

Mass Effect 1 = AAA
Mass Effect 2 = A

Fixed

Madtoker wrote:

DemonWolf wrote:

Yeah! I agree with most of those! Gears, killzone and uncharted shouldnt have such a high rating. A good rating, yes but not AAA IMO.
Btw red dead deserves AAA I think. But just a straight up 90

WHAT DRUGS HAVE YOU BEEN ON?

LOL Yeah I'm sure it takes drugs to see that gears is a repetitive albeit fun game but not worth AAA, to see that uncharted is merely tomb raider on rails with nice visuals but which no one plays anymore because it was fun only for a couple of hours, too see that killzone isnt any better than the average shooting game with nice graphics, sloppy controls and completely overshadowed by Halo Reach.

DemonWolf wrote:

DarkSwarm85 wrote:

Mass Effect 1 = AAAA
Mass Effect 2 = AAA

Fixed

Fixed again.

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

DemonWolf wrote:

DarkSwarm85 wrote:

Mass Effect 1 = AAAA
Mass Effect 2 = AAA

Fixed

Fixed again.

Okay, deal.

wtf is wrong with you guys, ME2 is so much better than the first one.

Fuck Metacritic. CVG, GameTrailers and IGN are the reviews I look at when buying a game. A load of people have found flaws in their (Metacritic) system.

Yet another reason I never trust the reviewer, just my own opinion.

Stoney wrote:

Fuck Metacritic. CVG, GameTrailers and IGN are the reviews I look at when buying a game. A load of people have found flaws in their (Metacritic) system.

I noticed another flaw in the system. Let's say a game gets 12 positive reviews, 7 mixed reviews, and 3 negative reviews. What happens is the the negative reviews can sometimes be so bad, they pull the overall average down, despite the fact that a majority of the reviewers enjoyed the game.

TRF wrote:

Stoney wrote:

Fuck Metacritic. CVG, GameTrailers and IGN are the reviews I look at when buying a game. A load of people have found flaws in their (Metacritic) system.

I noticed another flaw in the system. Let's say a game gets 12 positive reviews, 7 mixed reviews, and 3 negative reviews. What happens is the the negative reviews can sometimes be so bad, they pull the overall average down, despite the fact that a majority of the reviewers enjoyed the game.

Yea.Look at Reach, a couple of reviewers gave it a 8/10 but when you look at what all the other reviewers gave it, those 8/10's are in the minority.

Arbiteris wrote:

TRF wrote:

Stoney wrote:

Fuck Metacritic. CVG, GameTrailers and IGN are the reviews I look at when buying a game. A load of people have found flaws in their (Metacritic) system.

I noticed another flaw in the system. Let's say a game gets 12 positive reviews, 7 mixed reviews, and 3 negative reviews. What happens is the the negative reviews can sometimes be so bad, they pull the overall average down, despite the fact that a majority of the reviewers enjoyed the game.

Yea.Look at Reach, a couple of reviewers gave it a 8/10 but when you look at what all the other reviewers gave it, those 8/10's are in the minority.

It depends on the order the game is averaged. It does not matter of it is the minority or not, it will still down the game's average rating, depending on the order in which Metacritic averages it.

Deus Ex Machina wrote:

Arbiteris wrote:

TRF wrote:

Stoney wrote:

Fuck Metacritic. CVG, GameTrailers and IGN are the reviews I look at when buying a game. A load of people have found flaws in their (Metacritic) system.

I noticed another flaw in the system. Let's say a game gets 12 positive reviews, 7 mixed reviews, and 3 negative reviews. What happens is the the negative reviews can sometimes be so bad, they pull the overall average down, despite the fact that a majority of the reviewers enjoyed the game.

Yea.Look at Reach, a couple of reviewers gave it a 8/10 but when you look at what all the other reviewers gave it, those 8/10's are in the minority.

It depends on the order the game is averaged. It does not matter of it is the minority or not, it will still down the game's average rating, depending on the order in which Metacritic averages it.

And that is a flaw

Games arent getting the review scores they deserve simply because of a "bad" review or two

Yo Metacritic, I'm really happy for you, I'ma let you finish, but Fable 3 is one of the most underrated RPGs of all time, OF ALL TIME!

-Kayne West

Fable 3 AAA
MW2- A
GTA4- Below A
L4D- AAA
ME2- AA
Halo 3- AA
Halo Reach- Higher AAA
Alan Wake- Higher AA
Crackdown 2- Higher A
BFBC2- AAA
etc.