Most Overrated games of 2009

http://www.gamepro.com.au/slideshow/332675/9-most-overrated-games-of-2009/?image=1

I personally thought it was too harsh for a lot of these games.
Eg: L4D2, ODST, MW2, and even Uncharted 2!
I mean I agree UC2 is a little overrated, both times I played it I thought it was good but a little underwhelming. I still think it deserves AAA though which is why I'm a little shocked at the re-score: 89.

Who cares

are those guys for real some of those games are awesome, but if this is for real are they changing the scores or is it there opinion

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

I've heard GamePro was terrible. Now I know it's true.

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

ODSt's story wasnt forgettable.It was actually deep.They were also being creative showing alot of it in flashbacks

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

You always have something negative to say about any topic on this forum don't you?

ghost23 wrote:

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

You always have something negative to say about any topic on this forum don't you?

It's getting annoying....

Arbiteris wrote:

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

ODSt's story wasnt forgettable.It was actually deep.They were also being creative showing alot of it in flashbacks

It's his opinion dude. I don't think you're going to make him change and I do have similar opinion with you too.

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

Sequels are suppose to be similar to the 1st game.

Pickles wrote:

ghost23 wrote:

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

You always have something negative to say about any topic on this forum don't you?

It's getting annoying....

Well excuse the hell out of me for not being a slave to marketing & going all gaga over the same old shit. I don't have something negative to say I just say what's on my mind, and say how I feel about hings. Not my fault you feel different. I could feel the same way about your opinion on things... BAM!

MICHAEL wrote:

Pickles wrote:

ghost23 wrote:

MICHAEL wrote:

I'll agree with that list. None of those games made me want to by them. Especially that fake ass RTS Brutal Legends.
RE5 was lame because everything took for freaking ever to do & was so clunky, and no shooting & running was a def turn off.
MW2 was nothing, but MW1 reboxed with some new maps.
Halo ODST was Halo 3 with all the DLC, and a short forgettable story.
Left 4 Dead 2 same as MW2 same old shit repackaged.
UC2 still haven't gotten yet, but if it's like UC1 it's overrated.
Killzone 2 was nothing more then an average FPS with the decent graphics surely nothing to call home about, and the control scheme was ass.
haven't played Braid, DAO, or the Sims 3, but i have played sims 2, and I doubt it's anything amazing.

You always have something negative to say about any topic on this forum don't you?

It's getting annoying....

Well excuse the hell out of me for not being a slave to marketing & going all gaga over the same old shit. I don't have something negative to say I just say what's on my mind, and say how I feel about hings. Not my fault you feel different. I could feel the same way about your opinion on things... BAM!

You do have a point