Lineup Battle!!!!

Ok, heres what we're gonna do. Take the 10 best 2010 ps3 games (not on 360) and assign 10 of the best 2010 xbox 360 games to go against each one and we wait for each to come out and for each, add the ratings they get from Metacritic.
We'll judge which system has a better year from this.
So, ps3 fanboys and 360 fanboys, tell me what you want me to change for each system's top 10. Once that's done, we'll leave it and see who ends up on top.
Should there be a game superior to any on the list you would like to replace (even after ratings are released), I can do that.

So here is what I've done so far:

PS3: -------------- 360:

God Of War 3 ----- --------- Monster Hunter Frontier Online
Heavy Rain ----- --------------- Alan Wake
MAG (79) ----- ----------------- Halo Reach
Agent ----- ----------------------- Crackdown 2
Gran Turismo 5 ------ --------- Project Gotham Racing 5
The Agency ----- ------------ Splinter Cell Conviction
White Knight Chronicles ----------Fable III
Final Fantasy XIII Versus ----------- Mass Effect 2 (96)
The Last Guardian -------- Ninety Nine Nights 2
ModNation Racers ------- ------ Venetica


OTHER GAMES

3D Dot Game Heroes ----- ---------- Kingdom Under Fire II
Ar tonelico III ------- ----------- DeathSmiles
DC Universe Online ------- ------------ The Secret World: Dark Days are Coming
Final Fantasy XIV Online --------- Two Worlds II (possibly multiplat, if so.... Mechwarrior/Deadly Premonition/Majesty 2/Star Hammer/Space Ark/Zeno Clash/Miner Wars mmo/Scrap Metal/Magicka/Battle Of Atlantis/etc You choose lol)
Free Realms ----- --------- Huxley
Last Rebellion ---- ------- Metro 2033

oh crap PGR 5!!!! i never knew that was even in development

Static103 wrote:

oh crap PGR 5!!!! i never knew that was even in development

In November 2009, "Microsoft Executive Confirms PGR 5 in the Works"

demondragondude wrote:

Static103 wrote:

oh crap PGR 5!!!! i never knew that was even in development

In November 2009, "Microsoft Executive Confirms PGR 5 in the Works"

oh crap thanks bro, you've just made my day. i'm gonna buy this

Versus XIII is probably for a 2011 release. White K. Chonicles is already in Japan since 2008 and i think that is no big deal. On the 360 side N3 kinda sucked so i don't expect much from the sequel either, my money is on Kingdom Under Fire II.

Either way, the ones i want from PS3 side for now are only these:

God of War III
Heavy Rain
Last Guardion
Versus XIII

Has for the 360:

Halo Reach
Alan Wake
Crackdown 2
SC: Conviction
Mass Effect 2
Kingdom Under Fire II
METRO 2033
FABLE III
(not counting all those better multi-platform games)

Put down

3D Dot Game Heroes ----- ---------- Kingdom Under Fire II
Ar tonelico III ------- ----------- DeathSmiles
DC Universe Online ------- ------------ The Secret World: Dark Days are Coming
Final Fantasy XIV Online --------- Two Worlds II
Free Realms ----- --------- Huxley
Last Rebellion ---- ------- Metro 2033

PhunkGamer wrote:

Put down

3D Dot Game Heroes ----- ---------- Kingdom Under Fire II
Ar tonelico III ------- ----------- DeathSmiles
DC Universe Online ------- ------------ The Secret World: Dark Days are Coming
Final Fantasy XIV Online --------- Two Worlds II
Free Realms ----- --------- Huxley
Last Rebellion ---- ------- Metro 2033

I'm doing a top 10.... But I suppose I could do a top 20 or whatever. Talk it over with the other ppl. I won't add those now coz im on my iPod touch and it takes ages to do.

Static103 wrote:

demondragondude wrote:

Static103 wrote:

oh crap PGR 5!!!! i never knew that was even in development

In November 2009, "Microsoft Executive Confirms PGR 5 in the Works"

oh crap thanks bro, you've just made my day. i'm gonna buy this

lol you're welcome xD

good list

PS3

Yakuza 3 (yakuza's my favorite ps2 game game of all time)
Heavy Rain
God Of War 3
Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm 2 - Shippuuden (multiplatform)
Quantum Theory (both systems)

X-Box 360

Alan Wake
Project Gotham Racing 5
Mass Effect 2
Halo Reach
Metro 2033
Quantum Theory (both systems)

The only games I want from PS3 list are GT5 and FF Versus. And I want all those games on the 360 list.

What the hell is Halo: Reach? I've never heard of that game.

dreadraptor85 wrote:

What the hell is Halo: Reach? I've never heard of that game.

lmao! xD

dreadraptor85 wrote:

What the hell is Halo: Reach? I've never heard of that game.

I heard it was some kind of a arcadeish game where you reach for lightrings.

Halo is a light phenomena, it comes from greek and means literally "Ring".

Blixtstorm wrote:

dreadraptor85 wrote:

What the hell is Halo: Reach? I've never heard of that game.

I heard it was some kind of a arcadeish game where you reach for lightrings.

Halo is a light phenomena, it comes from greek and means literally "Ring".

Its a reach for rings.

demondragondude wrote:

Ok, heres what we're gonna do. Take the 10 best 2010 ps3 games (not on 360) and assign 10 of the best 2010 xbox 360 games to go against each one and we wait for each to come out and for each, add the ratings they get from Metacritic.
We'll judge which system has a better year from this.
So, ps3 fanboys and 360 fanboys, tell me what you want me to change for each system's top 10. Once that's done, we'll leave it and see who ends up on top.
Should there be a game superior to any on the list you would like to replace (even after ratings are released), I can do that.

So here is what I've done so far:

PS3: -------------- 360:

God Of War 3 ----- --------- Monster Hunter Frontier Online
Heavy Rain ----- --------------- Alan Wake
MAG (79) ----- ----------------- Halo Reach
Agent ----- ----------------------- Crackdown 2
Gran Turismo 5 ------ --------- Project Gotham Racing 5
The Agency ----- ------------ Splinter Cell Conviction
White Knight Chronicles ----------Fable III
Final Fantasy XIII Versus ----------- Mass Effect 2 (96)
The Last Guardian -------- Ninety Nine Nights 2
ModNation Racers ------- ------ Venetica


OTHER GAMES

3D Dot Game Heroes ----- ---------- Kingdom Under Fire II
Ar tonelico III ------- ----------- DeathSmiles
DC Universe Online ------- ------------ The Secret World: Dark Days are Coming
Final Fantasy XIV Online --------- Two Worlds II (possibly multiplat, if so.... Mechwarrior/Deadly Premonition/Majesty 2/Star Hammer/Space Ark/Zeno Clash/Miner Wars mmo/Scrap Metal/Magicka/Battle Of Atlantis/etc You choose lol)
Free Realms ----- --------- Huxley
Last Rebellion ---- ------- Metro 2033

only good thing on that list for 360 is alan wake and mass effect 2 rest are pile of shit but ps3 line up looks great cept for the agency and modnation racers(beta is boring)

SlyDevilAlwaysCumsBak wrote:

demondragondude wrote:

Ok, heres what we're gonna do. Take the 10 best 2010 ps3 games (not on 360) and assign 10 of the best 2010 xbox 360 games to go against each one and we wait for each to come out and for each, add the ratings they get from Metacritic.
We'll judge which system has a better year from this.
So, ps3 fanboys and 360 fanboys, tell me what you want me to change for each system's top 10. Once that's done, we'll leave it and see who ends up on top.
Should there be a game superior to any on the list you would like to replace (even after ratings are released), I can do that.

So here is what I've done so far:

PS3: -------------- 360:

God Of War 3 ----- --------- Monster Hunter Frontier Online
Heavy Rain ----- --------------- Alan Wake
MAG (79) ----- ----------------- Halo Reach
Agent ----- ----------------------- Crackdown 2
Gran Turismo 5 ------ --------- Project Gotham Racing 5
The Agency ----- ------------ Splinter Cell Conviction
White Knight Chronicles ----------Fable III
Final Fantasy XIII Versus ----------- Mass Effect 2 (96)
The Last Guardian -------- Ninety Nine Nights 2
ModNation Racers ------- ------ Venetica


OTHER GAMES

3D Dot Game Heroes ----- ---------- Kingdom Under Fire II
Ar tonelico III ------- ----------- DeathSmiles
DC Universe Online ------- ------------ The Secret World: Dark Days are Coming
Final Fantasy XIV Online --------- Two Worlds II (possibly multiplat, if so.... Mechwarrior/Deadly Premonition/Majesty 2/Star Hammer/Space Ark/Zeno Clash/Miner Wars mmo/Scrap Metal/Magicka/Battle Of Atlantis/etc You choose lol)
Free Realms ----- --------- Huxley
Last Rebellion ---- ------- Metro 2033

only good thing on that list for 360 is alan wake and mass effect 2 rest are pile of shit but ps3 line up looks great cept for the agency and modnation racers(beta is boring)

GTFO Altair who whoever came first.

360 has 2010 on lockdown.

I don't think GoW3 should be up against MH since they are nothing alike.
But that's just me.
GoW3 is going to get good reviews regardless simply because it's GoW.

I can't wait for MH though, I have wanted a console MH for such a long time

360

White Knight Chronicles is already a fail (65 Metacritic) , so the 360 is beating the PS3 3-0 so far. Seeing as Halo Reach and Fable III will slaughter MAG and WKC.

microsoft aint playing any jokes this year