360 vs. PS3 2011

Just for fun. Going by games that are released for PS3/360 this year, have at least a Metacritic score of 70 and are not available on both consoles.

PS3:
90+: (4) Little Big Planet 2, MLB 11: The Show, ICO/SotC Collection, Uncharted 3
80-89: (7) Killzone 3, Tomb Raider Trilogy, Prince of Persia Trilogy, inFAMOUS 2, God of War Origins Collection, Resistance 3, Disgaea 4
70-79: (6) Yakuza 4, Motorstorm: Apocalypse, No More Heroes: Heroes Paradise, Atelier Totori, , Ratchet & Clank: All 4 One, The House of the Dead: Overkill - Extended Cut

PSN:
90+ (0)
80-89 (4) TetrisHD, PixelJunk Shooter 2, Alien Zombie Megadeath, Puzzle Dimension
70-79 (9) Tales from Space: About a Blob, Chime Super Deluxe, Hamilton's Great Adventure, Back to the Future: The Game, Rochard, Eufloria, Sideway: New York, Rocketbirds: Hardboiled Chicken, inFamous: Festival of Blood

360:
90+: (2) Gears of War 3, Forza Motorsport 4
80-89: (2) Sesame Street: Once Upon a Monster, Dance Central 2
70-79: (2) Divinity II: The Dragon Knight Saga, The Gunstringer

XBLA:
90+ (0)
80-89 (11) ilomilo, Torchlight, The Dishwasher: Vampire Smile, Trenched, Ms. Splosion Man, Bastion,
Toy Soldiers: Cold War, Orcs Must Die! Guardian Heroes, Radiant Silvergun, Tropico 4
70-79 (9) Zeit Squared, Full House Poker, Pinball FX 2: MARS, Bangai-O HD: Missile Fury,
The Adventures of Shuggy, Half-Minute Hero: Super Mega Neo Climax, Boulder Dash-XL,
Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet, Fruit Ninja Kinect

I think multiplats would be ok to post too as long as the score for each system is consistent(say if deadspace2 had a higher score on 360 or vice-versa).

Cylon8472 wrote:

I think multiplats would be ok to post too as long as the score for each system is consistent(say if deadspace2 had a higher score on 360 or vice-versa).

Generally, multiplats on PS3 and 360 receive close to the same score. Even if one version is slightly better then the other, it's still the same game.

When one is reviewed higher than the other that just means that either Xbox magazines or Playstation magazines gave that game a higher score.

I know it fits under the guidelines that MLD originally set out, but Tetris HD is really pushing it to be counted as a PSN game.

ghost23 wrote:

I know it fits under the guidelines that MLD originally set out, but Tetris HD is really pushing it to be counted as a PSN game.

Why is that? It's got a Metacritic score and it's got its own online and offline cooperative and competitive modes and is in HD. It's not the original Tetris at all.

ghost23 wrote:

I know it fits under the guidelines that MLD originally set out, but Tetris HD is really pushing it to be counted as a PSN game.

Perfect Dark counted for us last year though.

TRF wrote:

ghost23 wrote:

I know it fits under the guidelines that MLD originally set out, but Tetris HD is really pushing it to be counted as a PSN game.

Why is that? It's got a Metacritic score and it's got its own online and offline cooperative and competitive modes and is in HD. It's not the original Tetris at all.

I know I know, but it's still Tetris though! You know what I mean.

ghost23 wrote:

TRF wrote:

ghost23 wrote:

I know it fits under the guidelines that MLD originally set out, but Tetris HD is really pushing it to be counted as a PSN game.

Why is that? It's got a Metacritic score and it's got its own online and offline cooperative and competitive modes and is in HD. It's not the original Tetris at all.

I know I know, but it's still Tetris though! You know what I mean.

A lot of people love Tetris. A new paint job and some added modes can work wonders for old classics. Just look at Pac Man CE DX and Space Invaders Extreme. Both are amazing.

its my criteria so I cant complain.

but i know 360 is gonna loose this year. You cant win em all, after all we did win 2010, but the question is how much it will loose this year. XBLA and kinect games are a wild card at this point.

Now by loose I mean the number of A-AAA games.

Braod picture wise it looks like this year will still be another year where we hold 2nd place and have more TOTAL A-AAA games, but again, this should be interesting to see.

I just wish (wish mind you) that there wasn't all this animosity to each others choice of gaming. I only have a playstation but I'd definitly play and xbox game if somone asked. on topic though, I just hope this year the Devs put more effort into creativity and less into what sells easier. Movies that sell easier tend to be terrible unlike the movies that are herd to find, and I found some very rare movies.

I am genuinely upset that Explodemon didn't get too great reviews... I think it deserves more praise tbh

I was surprised by how bad DC Universe Online scored. Blare, from X-Play, speaks very highly of it, but other then him, the feedback has been overwhelmingly negative. I'm too scared to try it because once you play it on your PS3, it won't work on any other. So if I end up hating it, I won't ever be able to sell it. I'll pass on DCUO until there's a very deep price cut.

I played the DCUO beta. Very fun.

MLB 11 scored AAA. Torchlight AA

Invincible wrote:

MLB 11 scored AAA. Torchlight AA

MLB has 5 reviews so far. Wait until theres a decent number of reviews

Another update already. Motorstorm is currently sitting at 80.

ghost23 wrote:

Invincible wrote:

MLB 11 scored AAA. Torchlight AA

MLB has 5 reviews so far. Wait until theres a decent number of reviews

Noone was saying that while Killzone3 had 2 reviews at the time of its releasing.

Skycrawler wrote:

ghost23 wrote:

Invincible wrote:

MLB 11 scored AAA. Torchlight AA

MLB has 5 reviews so far. Wait until theres a decent number of reviews

Noone was saying that while Killzone3 had 2 reviews at the time of its releasing.

With the system that Metacritic runs with, a game will very rarely increase in metascore with more reviews. The big reviews (IGN, Gamespot, Gametrailers etc.) are posted first and are weighted in a specific way. In the case of Killzone 3, it was AA with only a few reviews but it was extremely unlikely that it was ever going to go up to AAA.
With MLB, since it is already sitting at 91 with 6 reviews, it is very likely that it will drop a few points. I remember Reach dropped from 95 to 91 once all the reviews were added.

Bump for Yakuza 4

Good start for PS3.

Now MLB 2011 AA with 89%

Damn thats a low blow.

Tomb Raider and Prince of Persia Trilogies both scored in the 80's. Splinter Cell has one coming out soon too.

updated

Well go ahead and add Uncharted 3, its resting at 94