Alan Wake Reviews thread

The guys at Alan Wake forums are doing it, and i think its good way to put everything that we know from Alan Wake reviews in this thread.

Has of now these are the sites that review the game and they're respective scores:

1UP - B+ (85%)
3dJuegos - 8.5/10
411mania - 9.1/10
About - 4/5 (80%)
Aeropause - 4.5/5 (90%)
C&VG - 9/10
Capsule Computers - 9/10
Chud - 7.5/10
CinemaBlend - 4/5 (80%)
Co-Optimus - 5/5 (100%)
Destructoid - 9/10
Eurogamer.de - 9/10
Eurogamer.es - 8/10
Eurogamer.net - 7/10
Everyeye.it - 7.8/10
Evil Avatar - 4/5 (80%)
FileFront - 91/100
FZ SE - 4/5 (80%)
G4TV - 4/5 (80%)
GameArena.com.au - 8/10
GameBlog.fr - 5/5 (100%)
GameDaily - 9/10
GameInformer - 8.5/10
GameKult.fr - 8/10
GamePro - 4/5 (80%)
Gamer365.hu - 9.5/10
GameReactor.dk - 8/10
GameReactor.eu - 7/10
GameReactor.fi - 9/10
GameRevolution - A- (90%)
Gamestar.hu - 93/100
Gamesurf.tiscali.it - 8/10
Gamezone - 8/10
Game Trailers - 8.6/10
Gamers Revenge - 9/10
Games Radar 8/10
Giant Bomb - 4/5 (80%)
Gladriel - 9/10
Hardgame2 - 10/10
IGN - 9/10
IGN AU - 8.5/10
IGN UK - 8/10
INC Gamers - 9.1/10
iTWire - 10/10
Jatekok.hu - 9.5/10
JeuxActu - 17/20 (85%)
JeuxVideo.com - 17/20 (85%)
Jeuxvideo.fr - 4/5 (80%)
JoBlo - 7.9/10
Juegos DB - 9.5/10
Just Push Start - 4.5/5 (90%)
JVN.com - 18/20 (90%)
Loud Mouthed Gamers - 9/10
Meristation - 9/10
NowGamer - 6.8/10
NZGamer.com - 8.5/10
OXM - 90/100
OXM UK - 80/100
PCDome.hu - 9/10
PCMag - 4.5/5 (90%)
Pelit (Magazine) - 87%
Peliplaneetta - 86/100
PerezStart - 9/10
PlanetXbox360 - 9.2/10
Plaza.fi - 10/10
Spaziogames.it - 9/10
Techland - 9/10
TheKoalition - 9/10
The Escapist Magazine - 5/5 (100%)
Tilt.tv - 9/10
Todojuegos.com - 9.5/10
Tom's Games - 18/20 (90%)
UGO - B+ (85%)
Xbox-Mag.net - 18/20 (90%)
Xbox360Achievements.com - 92%
Xbox Addict - 93%
XXLGaming - 95/100
Vandal Online - 9/10
VicioJuegos - 90/100
VideoGamer.com - 9/10
Worthplaying - 9/10
Pelaaja - 9/10

looks good so far imo

Lt Xplosi wrote:

looks good so far imo

Remedy son, never fails!

i wasnt very exited for this game but after the reviews it is getting i think i will buy it

NowGamer - 6.8/10???? WTF!!!!
anyway it has more 9's than 8's or 7's so its most likely going to be a low AAA

AndrejTheReviewer wrote:

NowGamer - 6.8/10???? WTF!!!!
anyway it has more 9's than 8's or 7's so its most likely going to be a low AAA

So far its a mid AA. But hopefully it'll pull up to a AAA.

AndrejTheReviewer wrote:

NowGamer - 6.8/10???? WTF!!!!
anyway it has more 9's than 8's or 7's so its most likely going to be a low AAA

It would be AAA if it weren't for those couple of retarded critics who gave it A or 6/10.
Pfft.

Games which I believe deserve AAA and only got high AA:

Heavy Rain
Fable II
Left 4 Dead 2
Demon Souls
Left 4 Dead 1
Alan Wake

some of the those reviews are retarded! i mean unplausible abandoned equipment? yeah no one has flash lights guns or batteries....

For a new IP, Alan Wake did great. 86% on Gamerankings and 85% on metacritic. Keep in mind the prequel to the 2009 GOTY which was Uncharted 1 was also AA. Alan Wake has potential (the game, not the man LOL).

i hope it'll be AAA

alan wake is 85 so far with 44 reviews which is bs. reviews in these days r fanboys well atleast were tied in aa, wining in a, but losing in aaa

joe11 wrote:

alan wake is 85 so far with 44 reviews which is bs. reviews in these days r fanboys well atleast were tied in aa, wining in a, but losing in aaa

You are acting exactly like a PS3 fanboy by calling the reviews biased. 85 is still an amazing game that everyone should play.

agreed Heavy rain for ps3 didnt get AAA i think
but i still think HR is cool

demondragondude wrote:

AndrejTheReviewer wrote:

NowGamer - 6.8/10???? WTF!!!!
anyway it has more 9's than 8's or 7's so its most likely going to be a low AAA

It would be AAA if it weren't for those couple of retarded critics who gave it A or 6/10.
Pfft.

Games which I believe deserve AAA and only got high AA:

Heavy Rain
Fable II
Left 4 Dead 2
Demon Souls
Left 4 Dead 1
Alan Wake

Demon's Souls IS AAA, it has a 90 on metacritic

i remember when most guys here were hyping it like a AAA game and claiming how the review scores are gonna beat Heavy Rain which didn' which i found really funny a few days ago. Anyways alan wake is a good game ans 84 is still good and i'm buying the limited edition since im a horror fan and was my most anticipated xbox 360 game of the year

Static103 wrote:

i remember when most guys here were hyping it like a AAA game and claiming how the review scores are gonna beat Heavy Rain which didn' which i found really funny a few days ago. Anyways alan wake is a good game ans 84 is still good and i'm buying the limited edition since im a horror fan and was my most anticipated xbox 360 game of the year

The game not even full out yet, and has half the reviews of Heavy Rain on Metacritic. I mean 51 versus 106 reviews? That's kinda of a big gap althought the % is small between the two games. If Metacritic put all the scores i put here plus some more that are been released every day (8's and 9's) the game would be at least 89%.