360 VS PS3 (A, AA, AAA) 2010 FINALIZED

TBH, Kinect is kicking ass. I didn't expect Dance Central reviews to be so high.

GeneralMLD wrote:

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/the-fight-lights-out

lol the Moves last hopes of getting a good game scored really, really low lol

singstar dance for move also looks to bomb as well (below 70)

Holly shit, that's low as fuck :O and it's a first party game :S

well your shape fitness evolved made "A" but ill wait for more reviews cause it could still go either way

GeneralMLD wrote:

well your shape fitness evolved made "A" but ill wait for more reviews cause it could still go either way

EA Sports Active 2 looks like a much better fitness game than Your Shape and the Kinect versions of Active 2 will be the best version since the Ps3 and Wii versions are gimped cause of the limitations of Move/Wiimote.

ghost23 wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

well your shape fitness evolved made "A" but ill wait for more reviews cause it could still go either way

EA Sports Active 2 looks like a much better fitness game than Your Shape and the Kinect versions of Active 2 will be the best version since the Ps3 and Wii versions are gimped cause of the limitations of Move/Wiimote.

Yup multiplats are always better on 360. Looks like this may follow suit with Kinect in several cases.

Unfortunately Bloody Good Time lost it's good momentum of a AA and A rating and has now only got a rating of 65. The reason for it I believe is the lack of maps. There are only 3 :/

Why is "I Love the 80's" on the list? It's not even listed on Metacritic at all.

Mecha wrote:

Why is "I Love the 80's" on the list? It's not even listed on Metacritic at all.

It was, but when Metacritic changed a couple of months ago when it removed Xbox, PS2, etc. reviews it also removed the reviews of games not in the US. Lips I love the 80's is available in Europe and Japan (I think), but not the US. It's listed on GameRankings though.

BlackStigma wrote:

Mecha wrote:

Why is "I Love the 80's" on the list? It's not even listed on Metacritic at all.

It was, but when Metacritic changed a couple of months ago when it removed Xbox, PS2, etc. reviews it also removed the reviews of games not in the US. Lips I love the 80's is available in Europe and Japan (I think), but not the US. It's listed on GameRankings though.

So we should remove it then, since it's not on Metacritic.

TRF wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

Mecha wrote:

Why is "I Love the 80's" on the list? It's not even listed on Metacritic at all.

It was, but when Metacritic changed a couple of months ago when it removed Xbox, PS2, etc. reviews it also removed the reviews of games not in the US. Lips I love the 80's is available in Europe and Japan (I think), but not the US. It's listed on GameRankings though.

So we should remove it then, since it's not on Metacritic.

eh that's not exactly fair. Some games come out in the US first or don't come out in Europe but those count apparently. Like Demon's Souls, it didn't come out in Europe until this year but it was still counted for 2009.

plus side i noticed that an old 2010 SPace Ark crossed into the "A" category for XBLA

as for lips i love the 80s.......i distinctly remember it scoring "A" this year. I dont know why they took it down cause I cant find it either.

but it was a 2010 release and it was "A". This aint like ps1 classics.........this game was reviewed by reviewers

It's not on Metacritic, though.

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

But it exists and it was rated. It's on gamesrankings too.

I still can't figure out why the Sly Collection has no reviews at all. The previous collection, which was the GOW collection, was AAA. Why is that? is it due to COD:BO?

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Reposting! N00b

I think "Lips: I Love the 80's" should be removed if it's not listed on Metacritic.

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Yeah you're right it shouldn't count if it's not on metacritic, but no more complaining about PS1 classics, because you know, they're not on metacritic.

Mecha wrote:

I think "Lips: I Love the 80's" should be removed if it's not listed on Metacritic.

The quotes, CyperpunkCentral?

BlackStigma wrote:

Mecha wrote:

I think "Lips: I Love the 80's" should be removed if it's not listed on Metacritic.

The quotes, CyperpunkCentral?

I'm not CC. I'm Mecha.

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Yeah you're right it shouldn't count if it's not on metacritic, but no more complaining about PS1 classics, because you know, they're not on metacritic.

Well, you can either include Lips AND include PSone Classics, or get rid of both. If you're gonna make a rule that only Metacritic games count, then you have to abide by it fully or not. No exceptions.

TRF wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Yeah you're right it shouldn't count if it's not on metacritic, but no more complaining about PS1 classics, because you know, they're not on metacritic.

Well, you can either include Lips AND include PSone Classics, or get rid of both. If you're gonna make a rule that only Metacritic games count, then you have to abide by it fully or not. No exceptions.

That's what I was implying...

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Yeah you're right it shouldn't count if it's not on metacritic, but no more complaining about PS1 classics, because you know, they're not on metacritic.

Well, you can either include Lips AND include PSone Classics, or get rid of both. If you're gonna make a rule that only Metacritic games count, then you have to abide by it fully or not. No exceptions.

That's what I was implying...

I know. I'm agreeing with you. I just thought you were saying that I, specifically, was complaining about PSone Classics.

TRF wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

BlackStigma wrote:

TRF wrote:

GeneralMLD wrote:

TRF wrote:

It's not on Metacritic, though.

it was on metacritic......but some oversight got in the way.

It's not on Metacritic, though.

Yeah you're right it shouldn't count if it's not on metacritic, but no more complaining about PS1 classics, because you know, they're not on metacritic.

Well, you can either include Lips AND include PSone Classics, or get rid of both. If you're gonna make a rule that only Metacritic games count, then you have to abide by it fully or not. No exceptions.

That's what I was implying...

I know. I'm agreeing with you. I just thought you were saying that I, specifically, was complaining about PSone Classics.

i see your point but this is unique in that it WAS on metacritic and it scored "A". It was there. PS1 classics are never reviewed.

for some reason the game doesnt exist on the site, it was taken down for some reason. But it was there and i think its wrong to take it down due to a web site technicality.