Natal vs Move

Natal - Glorifed EyeToy
Move - Glorified WiiMote

Now, while Natal's technology is a much larger improvement over the eyetoy then the Move's jump over the Wiimote, they are essentially the same in that you will receive a very similar experience. Feel free to give your opinion as this is mine.

I completely agree. Neither are original, and both are for teh monies. I doubt I'll be getting either.

Agreed

Chances are Natal will be mainly casual, so I'll probably give it a miss.

Move is a rip-off of the Wii-mote, but from what I've seen I've liked. Still chances are I'll be giving that one a miss also.

There is a more chance of Move succeeding Natal will be a straight out Fail or successes.

Dont really care about either Natal or Move.Wiimote is good enough for me

As a fan of motion controls, I'm excited for both. But what worries me about Natal is the lack of a trigger. It seems like that could really gimp the hardware from being used in non-casual games. And what worries me about PS Move is developers not supporting it. Because it seems like it could give me the experience I always wanted on the Wii...IF developers take the time to do it right.

I hope they both sell well enough we see developers push them to their limits and not get a bunch of crappy shovelware mini-games.

Invincible wrote:

As a fan of motion controls, I'm excited for both. But what worries me about Natal is the lack of a trigger. It seems like that could really gimp the hardware from being used in non-casual games. And what worries me about PS Move is developers not supporting it. Because it seems like it could give me the experience I always wanted on the Wii...IF developers take the time to do it right.

I hope they both sell well enough we see developers push them to their limits and not get a bunch of crappy shovelware mini-games.

You're asking for too much. Crappy shovelware games are unavoidable. Just hope that we don't get just crappy shovelware games.

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

Like I said before, the difference between the Wiimote and Move is the sames as Natal and the Eyetoy. They will both sense depth in 3D space.
Simple as that.

-jaz350z- wrote:

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

Like I said before, the difference between the Wiimote and Move is the sames as Natal and the Eyetoy. They will both sense depth in 3D space.
Simple as that.

did you even read his comment?

arnt god of war wrote:

-jaz350z- wrote:

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

Like I said before, the difference between the Wiimote and Move is the sames as Natal and the Eyetoy. They will both sense depth in 3D space.
Simple as that.

did you even read his comment?

Did you even read mine?

-jaz350z- wrote:

arnt god of war wrote:

-jaz350z- wrote:

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

Like I said before, the difference between the Wiimote and Move is the sames as Natal and the Eyetoy. They will both sense depth in 3D space.
Simple as that.

did you even read his comment?

Did you even read mine?

I can do that too. Watch.

Like I said before, the difference between Wii Motion Plus and Move is minuscule while Natal has high tech hardware/software and Eyetoy is a shitty webcam with shitty games. Natal can sense depth in 3D space and Eyetoy struggles to capture any movement at all.

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

The same can be said for PlayStation Move. Like it's going to do things that's impossible on the Wii. In fact Project Natal is more of a copy of the PlayStation Eye then EyeToy, since the technology is more advanced. And the funny thing is PlayStation Move is using the PlayStation Eye for it's motion sensing. So basically PlayStation Move is like Project Natal and Wii Motion Plus all in one.

Natal is stupid, Move is stupid. Have fun with your motion controls, it's the good old fashioned controller for me.

don't want either as I like to have a proper controller in my hand, These controllers are aimed at getting Casual gamers over from the Wii to the either of the other platforms.

These are not really for Hardcore gamers.

TheJubJub57212 wrote:

Natal is stupid, Move is stupid. Have fun with your motion controls, it's the good old fashioned controller for me.

Of course, but Motion controls can be fun some times too.

343_Guilty_Spark wrote:

PSeye is a crappy webcam with crappy games. Natal is a high tech 3D sensing depth camera system with advanced software interpretation. The only thing similar about them is that Natal has a camera on it and the PS2eye IS a camera. What will be done on Natal is impossible on PSeye.

Nothing on Move is impossible with a Wii Motion Plus. It might be slightly more precis, but not impossible.

That's why Move is a rip off and Natal isn't.

no they are both ripoffs yet i think natal will achieve more in sales since the eyetoy was last generation.
They are both for casuals and will both fail imo

lol none of should buy this motion control crap so it fails, i only bought a wii because u could use a gamecube controller